MDX or Pilot??

  • Thread starter Thread starter WKH
  • Start date Start date
W

WKH

i am looking for a 7 passengers SUV

I wonder which one is better MDX or Pilot?? I am totally new to SUV...

Is there any other SUV that can seat 7 passengers?

thanks for your informations
 
i am looking for a 7 passengers SUV

I wonder which one is better MDX or Pilot?? I am totally new to SUV...

Is there any other SUV that can seat 7 passengers?

thanks for your informations
Click to expand...

If you can afford the MDX, go for it. I have a Pilot, but if I had
just a bit more cash for a downpayment, I would've went for the MDX.
Don't get me wrong, my Pilot is a fine vehicle, but hey, if you can
afford to drive an Acura, why not? Plus, my Pilot just got higher
roll-over safety ratings than the MDX according to the NHTSA,
http://www.nhtsa.dot.gov/NCAP/Cars/2003SUVs.html.

Go check out www.honda-pilot.org and www.acuramdx.org for discussions
on pros and cons of buying one or the other. You can always ask more
questions after you read up on some of the threads of discussions on
your inquiry. Good luck!
 
You're recommending the MDX, even though the Pilot has better safety
ratings??
 
I guess I am. But it's not as though there's a hug disparity between
MDX's and Pilot's safety ratings. Would you agree? Very marginal at
the most. There are people out there who recommend other SUV's which
has far inferior safety ratings over the Pilot and worse yet, there
are countless out there that drive them.

You make it sound as though I've just committed some great sin
recommending the MDX over the Pilot. Even in www.honda-pilot.org, of
which I'm a member and frequent contributor, I've always said that I'd
get an MDX over the Pilot if I could've afforded it. Quite a few
concurred.
 
I guess you're right... chances are, if people are really intrested in
safety, they wouldn't usually buy an SUV to begin with.

That said, safety IS very important for me and my family, but hey, I'm wierd
that way.
 
THE PILOT SEATS 8 PEOPLE
Click to expand...


I took a short ride in the '03 Pilot the other day. It is surprisingly
luxurious (for a truck) with the better trim models, has a DVD player etc.
I believe it is made by Isuzu.


You should take a test drive of both vehicles before you decide.
 
Hi,
Even safest car in the world won't help if stupid driver drives it.
Tony
 
So then, is your car absolutely the SAFEST rated car out there then?
I didn't think so.

But, if you were so much concerned about the safety of your family, so
much more so than all the SUV buyers as you have claimed, then
wouldn't you buy a car out there with the SAFEST rating, with all the
latest passenger protection features, such as the side and ceiling air
curtains, the side impact airbags, the anti-rollover systems, the
anti-skil control system and etc?

Does your car have all those features? No? Oh, how come????
Wouldn't you be driving your family in a car with all those safety
features since you said you were so concerned with your family's
safety? Would this mean then, that you care less about your family's
safety than those people who are indeed driving around in a car with
all those safety features I mentioned? By your logic and claim, yes,
it would make you to be a less caring father and husband since you're
not driving a car equipped with ALL those safety features.

Hard to argue with that, right? After all, it's your own logic and
implication you expressed yourself.

Lemme teach you something. You see, sarcasm only works when you're in
the right. SELF RIGHTEOUSNESS though, will always make you out to
look like an idiot. You're right about one thing though, you are
fucking weird.
 
Wow, Steve, looks like I struck a nerve. Sorry.

The truth is, some people put safety as a high priority, some people don't.
That's called making a choice, Steve.

Given the choice of two vehicles in the same class, one which offers better
safety than the other, the choice would be pretty simple to me. But hey,
like I said, I'm wierd that way, I value safety (and fuel economy) above
other aspects. Yes, by the way, I DO own the safest vehicle in my car's
class, thank you for asking.

Yes, the quip I made was a little silly, though there certainly is some
truth in it... if safety is that important to people, with a few exceptions,
they wouldn't buy SUVs. Now, some people are willing to take the chance
that something bad will not happen to them... and odds are, that's a good
bet. On the other hand, I choose differently.

Again, I apologize for hitting a nerve... but you really shouldn't let
someone's opinion get you in such a froth. Cheers.
 
Oh, man, Mark, I'm sincerely sorry for going off like that on you. I
really am. I guess I just received your remarks too much in a
negative way, which you didn't intend. My going off like that is a
bad habit held over from the old days when flame wars on newsgroups or
bbs's was a common, everyday occurrence.

Whenever I get even a small whiff of something that resembles an
unwarranted criticism, then the ugly side of me rears its head.

Anyhoo, thanks for your apology and please accecpt mine. Ciao!
 
Hey, Steve:

You DA MAN !!! Your choice of either an MDX or Pilot are great....you will
still be smiling when you either trade or sell your Pilot in 3, 5 or 10
years...you'll definitely make out better than an Explorer, Jeep Grand
Cherokee, Montero, Isuzu Trooper and other similar sized (non-comparable)
SUV's....

My 2 cents.

Vinnie
==========
 
Hey, Steve:

You DA MAN !!! Your choice of either an MDX or Pilot are great....you will
still be smiling when you either trade or sell your Pilot in 3, 5 or 10
years...you'll definitely make out better than an Explorer, Jeep Grand
Cherokee, Montero, Isuzu Trooper and other similar sized (non-comparable)
SUV's....

My 2 cents.
Click to expand...

Very good points. This guy from church I know just bought a brand new
Jeep Cherokee Ltd. and only 2 weeks after he bought it, the car
refused to remain running after he started the ignition. The car
would start, but only a few seconds after, it'd just turn off all by
itself. So far, he's had it at the dealer more than he's driven it.
Everytime the car was supposedly fixed, samething would happen later
that day or the nextday. One time, it even happened on the dealer lot
when he was there to pick up his car.

Up here in Canada, there's no such thing as a "Lemon Law", so he's
asked for either a another car or for a refund and so far, the
dealer's been asking him for more time to properly fix it. He said
he's gonna talk to a lawyer about it, but I really felt bad for him.
I mean, things like that thoroughly ruins the new car ownership
experience.
 
SUV's roll over. Get a car instead.
Steve Lee said:
Very good points. This guy from church I know just bought a brand new
Jeep Cherokee Ltd. and only 2 weeks after he bought it, the car
refused to remain running after he started the ignition. The car
would start, but only a few seconds after, it'd just turn off all by
itself. So far, he's had it at the dealer more than he's driven it.
Everytime the car was supposedly fixed, samething would happen later
that day or the nextday. One time, it even happened on the dealer lot
when he was there to pick up his car.

Up here in Canada, there's no such thing as a "Lemon Law", so he's
asked for either a another car or for a refund and so far, the
dealer's been asking him for more time to properly fix it. He said
he's gonna talk to a lawyer about it, but I really felt bad for him.
I mean, things like that thoroughly ruins the new car ownership
experience.
Click to expand...
 
I thought they were the same car, with only trim differences.
Click to expand...

Actually, they are not. Not the same footprint, but are very similar.
Pilot is wider, MDX is longer. Same drivetrain, but the MDX gets more
horsepower out of the same engine.
 
The earlier "Passport" was made by Isuzu for Honda. Pilot and MDX
are Hondas. Check your C.Reports repair ratings etc. and the IIHS crash
tests .. . if they've tested them >> http://www.iihs.org/
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest threads

Back
Top