?? Do all aftermket air-intake filters whistle ??

[JP]

I have a car, that is not a honda, but I know most of u honda owners like to
upgrade these cars for performance gains that is why I am asking u guys this
question. I bought this Akimoto universal air filter cone and replaced my
hard plastic hose with a soft plastic/rubber 3" hose coz its longer to reach
the corner so it can get fresh air. In the filter box, it said that it would
make a harmonic whistling sound, but I cannot hear that. I've heard cars
that do whislte and they say its the air intake. My question is, Do I have
something restricting the air suction? Should the air throtle bodies(my car
has two) be claned? Thanks for any sugestion.

 

[Bill B. Johnson]

I have a car, that is not a honda, but I know most of u honda owners like to
upgrade these cars for performance gains that is why I am asking u guys this
question. I bought this Akimoto universal air filter cone and replaced my
hard plastic hose with a soft plastic/rubber 3" hose coz its longer to reach
the corner so it can get fresh air. In the filter box, it said that it would
make a harmonic whistling sound, but I cannot hear that. I've heard cars
that do whislte and they say its the air intake. My question is, Do I have
something restricting the air suction? Should the air throtle bodies(my car
has two) be claned? Thanks for any sugestion.

I recently read some info. in a book related to this subject. The entire
chapter was related to air filters. The author of the book said that some
after market air filters make much more noise than regular air filters.
This is mainly because the car companies in most cases place the air
filters in a special plastic compartment that keeps down the noise. Many
makers of after market air filters require you to remove the plastic
compartments and mount a air filter that is NOT inside a plastic
compartment. Those air filters cause more noise--some more than
others--but work great. If you can't hear the noise--that's great. Keep
making use of the filter. The faster you go--the more sound it will make.
If you hear a whistling sound when going over 80 mph--don't worry about
it.

 

[CaptainKrunch]

Usually people that remove their "restrictive" stock air intake units and
put on a free flowing aftermarket item with no cover also have a loud ass
Folger's can on the back of their exhaust system which doesn't allow you to
hear anything happening under the hood anyway due to the excessive exhaust
noise.

Although the aftermarket air filter units do allow more airflow the air they
are sucking in is generally hot air from the engine compartment. The hot
air as we all know reduces horsepower on the scale of about 1 % for every 10
degree increase in air inlet temperature. Additionally, although I purchased
a K and N filter years ago for another vehicle, I am not sure I would do it
again. I have checked out a lot of information on the cleanable filters
with the gauze/cotten filter media on the internet and although it does
allow more air to pass it also allows more particulates to pass which
contribute to accelerated engine wear.

So I guess there is good and bad points to both units.

CaptainKrunch

 

[Bill B. Johnson]

Usually people that remove their "restrictive" stock air intake units and
put on a free flowing aftermarket item with no cover also have a loud ass
Folger's can on the back of their exhaust system which doesn't allow you to
hear anything happening under the hood anyway due to the excessive exhaust
noise.

Although the aftermarket air filter units do allow more airflow the air they
are sucking in is generally hot air from the engine compartment. The hot
air as we all know reduces horsepower on the scale of about 1 % for every 10
degree increase in air inlet temperature. Additionally, although I purchased
a K and N filter years ago for another vehicle, I am not sure I would do it
again. I have checked out a lot of information on the cleanable filters
with the gauze/cotten filter media on the internet and although it does
allow more air to pass it also allows more particulates to pass which
contribute to accelerated engine wear.

So I guess there is good and bad points to both units.

CaptainKrunch

Captain Krunch,
Excellent post. I could only add that some of the after market air
filters--used mainly by people that race their cars or enter car shows
--are made to allow fresh cold air to enter the filter. These types of
filter systems cost more but work better than those filters that are
mounted inside the engine compartment. Those expensive types of after
market filter systems are not needed for regular people that don't race or
display their cars in car shows.