Abeness said:
I've never paid much attention to bolt torques, for reasons described previously, so no. I went right to the Helm manual for my Honda, skipped Chilton's/Haynes entirely after some reports of errors, and I wanted the full monty.
A wise practice. Thanks for the link.
Likewise, re the link from Bolt Science (in the other thread you started).
Nice site.
I couldn't resist seeing if there was commentary on how to use the torque ranges in the Ford Chilton manuals. I checked and couldn't find anything. But for the record, some examples of ranges from the Chilton manual for Ford Full Size Vans, 1989-1996:
Wheel lug nuts on 1996 E-250: 126-170 ft-lbs
Shock absorber top mount nut: 25-35 ft-lbs.
Brake caliper mounting bolts: 22-26 ft-lbs.
Exhaust manifold bolts: 18-24 ft-lbs.
Stabilizer bar lock nut: 40-60 ft-lbs.
Oil pan bolts: 9-12 ft lbs.
So for this sample, the specified torque varies from 18% to 50% higher than the lowest value of toque specified.
Many Chilton manuals also have the following commentary (very much in the same vein as some of the material at the boltscience.com site):
[Paraphrasing] When tightening a bolt, torque ends up being "distributed" over three regions:
50% -- overcomes friction between the bolt head and the base surface 40% -- overcomes thread friction 10% -- develops a useful clamp load (which is where bolt tension and the whole purpose of a bolt come in)
These %s reinforce Tegger's original point: Change the friction between threads (or head and base) a little, and it will re-distribute a given applied torque such that bolt tension rises (for better or worse, as the application indicates).
What to shoot for? To me, the point is that achieving the correct holding power (a.k.a. clamping force) is a fairly inexact science (which of course is true of most engineering, depending on how one defines "exact"). One just can't consistently estimate with much "accuracy" the frictional resisting force for a given bolt that's been used many times. It's going to change over time, too, probably. But this should make no one uncomfortable. Factors of safety make the world go round. Start at the lower end of the torque range. If the bolt comes loose sooner than expected, increase the torque.
Also, one's torque wrench may, after years of use, be off by as much as say, 20%. A big deal? I'd say only with respect to undertorquing.
After all this, I suppose I'd regret my torque wrench purchases of the last year except that they do ensure uniformity on, for example, lug nut bolts and valve covers. That's half the battle in ensuring a secure wheel, valve cover, etc.