another grease question: bolt threads

Abeness

Usenet Archive
Joined
Aug 4, 2004
Messages
460
Reaction score
0
I can use a touch of just any old grease to lube bolt threads, right? E.g. the bolts attaching the slave cylinder to the tranny. Or should I avoid this so as to lessen the risk of over-tightening them? I do plan to use a torque wrench. While I'm careful, I sure don't want to run the risk of stripping out an aluminum block.
 
There's a grease specifically designed to prevent rust around bolt threads. It's conventionally called "Anti-seize" and has been around for decades in the auto and many industries that have machinery.

There are a few different grades of "Anti-seize." I buy the grey stuff (which is perhaps the most frequently used) from Autozone or whoever has the cheapest. Read the labels and see if it has commentary about temperature applications.

A few bucks for a small tube. A few bucks more will buy you a nice-sized can. Only takes a little.

Anti-seizing bolts won't mess up the torque you apply.
 
Caroline said:
There's a grease specifically designed to prevent rust around bolt threads. It's conventionally called "Anti-seize" and has been around for decades in the auto and many industries that have machinery.

Thanks, Caroline.
 
"Caroline" sprach im

Anti-seizing bolts won't mess up the torque you apply.

Yes it does. Anti-seize and oil both reduce the friction of the threads against each other. If you use anti-seize, lower your torque wrench setting 10% to compensate for loss of friction.

Copper-based Loctite C5A is better than the aluminum compounds, such as Permatex 133H.
 
Yes it does. Anti-seize and oil both reduce the friction of the threads against each other.

It depends.

1.
If it's an old, somewhat rusted bolt, it may very well noticeably reduce the friction between male and female threads. And this is for the better.

2.
If it's a brand new bolt, the effects of the lubricant on static friction are going to be negligible.

Static friction. Go study up on it.
If you use anti-seize, lower your torque wrench setting 10% to compensate for loss of friction.

Don't do this. Final, torqued clearance between threads is not affected by anti-seize.
Copper-based Loctite C5A is better than the aluminum compounds, such as Permatex 133H.

But may be a waste of money, depending on the particular application.
 
"Caroline" sprach im

Static friction. Go study up on it.

Static friction is the force you need to overcome when breaking a bolt loose. It has nothing to do with *dynamic* friction, which is what you encounter when you tighten a bolt down.

Static friction is why that crank bolt is so hard to get loosened.

Dynamic friction is most definitely affected by lubrication on the threads. It's the reason why Honda warns against using any lubricant at all on the threads of the crank bolt.

If you use anti-seize on a bolt, you risk reducing dynamic friction to the point that your torque wrench will not show a correct reading, and you risk either overstretching the bolt or stripping the threads, hence the reduction in torque reading by 10%.

Even that 10% is dependent on how much lubricant you used. Use a small amount of one kind, and it will make little difference. Use a lot of another kind and it may reduce dynamic friction by half. As a general rule, 10% reduction is good.
 
TeGGer® said:
"Caroline" sprach im

Static friction is the force you need to overcome when breaking a bolt loose. It has nothing to do with *dynamic* friction, which is what you encounter when you tighten a bolt down.

Static friction is why that crank bolt is so hard to get loosened.

Dynamic friction is most definitely affected by lubrication on the threads. It's the reason why Honda warns against using any lubricant at all on the threads of the crank bolt.

If you use anti-seize on a bolt, you risk reducing dynamic friction to the point that your torque wrench will not show a correct reading, and you risk either overstretching the bolt or stripping the threads, hence the reduction in torque reading by 10%.

Even that 10% is dependent on how much lubricant you used. Use a small amount of one kind, and it will make little difference. Use a lot of another kind and it may reduce dynamic friction by half. As a general rule, 10% reduction is good.

i believe you both :)
 
Caroline said:
It depends.

1.
If it's an old, somewhat rusted bolt, it may very well noticeably reduce the friction between male and female threads. And this is for the better.

2.
If it's a brand new bolt, the effects of the lubricant on static friction are going to be negligible.

Static friction. Go study up on it.

nope, tegger has it on this one caroline...
 
TeGGer® said:
Static friction is the force you need to overcome when breaking a bolt loose. It has nothing to do with *dynamic* friction, which is what you encounter when you tighten a bolt down.

When one is doing the final torquing of a bolt, static friction has everything to do with it.
Static friction is why that crank bolt is so hard to get loosened.

Dynamic friction is most definitely affected by lubrication on the threads.

It's the reason why Honda warns against using any lubricant at all on the threads of the crank bolt.

Nope. http://www.honda.co.uk/owner/AccordManual/400/5-36.pdf page 2, "Apply oil to the bolt threads."

In addition, during operation the crankshaft pulley bolt heats and so stretches (expanding from the heat), allowing the crankshaft's rotation to tighten it. Thus after a few years of operation one has the notoriously tight crankshaft pulley bolt, experiencing torques far in excess of the torque the technician applies when replacing the belt.

snip
As a general rule, 10% reduction is good.

This is an old wives' tale.

You also have to think about
1. precisely where the anti-seize ends up on the bolt's threads
2. what the purpose of anti-seize is.

What surfaces is anti-seize protecting from rust buildup? Not the surfaces in closest contact.

Now there are applications where anti-seize is specifically prohibited, but they're rare, and from my reading it's often or always due to a concern other than overtorquing, such as the stuff chipping off when it's dry and contaminating something or another.

Lastly, you're omitting the reality that anti-seize overcomes or compensates for existing rust/detritus on a bolt. To say it somehow 'way overcompensates' for it (e.g. reducing thread dimensions somehow), is some kind of wild guess.

Caroline
"20+ years with anti-seize."
 
Caroline said:
Nope. http://www.honda.co.uk/owner/AccordManual/400/5-36.pdf page 2, "Apply oil to the bolt threads."

In addition, during operation the crankshaft pulley bolt heats and so stretches (expanding from the heat), allowing the crankshaft's rotation to tighten it. Thus after a few years of operation one has the notoriously tight crankshaft pulley bolt, experiencing torques far in excess of the torque the technician applies when replacing the belt.

snip

This is an old wives' tale.

Ugh. Strike this. I stand corrected on a few important points. Some reputable sources support Tegger's basic contention. The focus for cars tends to be (new) spark plug threads, but maybe this is only because this is where the DIYer is most likely to encounter problems. E.g.

"Most threads on spark plugs designed for aluminum head applications are precoated to reduce the risk of thread damage. Even so, some technicians apply a drop of antiseize compound to the plug threads before they go in for added insurance. General Motors, however, does not recommend this practice because antiseize acts like a lubricant and may allow the plugs to be overtightened - which can damage the threads. GM's advice is to reduce the tightening torque on the plugs 40 percent if antiseize is used on the threads."

-- Import Car, "Spark Plug Technology Charges Forward," Larry Carley, May 1999

From another source, take two brand new identical bolts. Lube one and keep the other dry. Torque each to X ft-lbs. Measure the bolt tension. Bolt tension (= a certain amount of "pull" in pounds on the bolt) is what the goal is. Torque accomplishes this but indirectly, so to speak.

Dry, the bolt tension will by Y.
With lubricant, the bolt tension is > Y.

Yes, it's due to reduced friction. Call it static or dynamic. It's less.

With an older bolt that is being re-used, I would hesitate to say whether the prescribed torque should be adjusted. Galling, for one, is likely to be present, and the lubricant may compensate for this 'just enough.' So I'd argue (for now), it's a guess as to whether the prescribed torque should be adjusted.

One may speculate as to why the Honda manual cited above says put a drop of oil on the crankshaft pulley bolt. E.g.
1. The prescribed torque assumes the bolt has a drop of oil on it.
2. A drop of oil does not significantly affect the tension in the bolt when torqued to spec.
3. The authors know the bolt will be tightened further by the crankshaft over time.

Then too I'm not eager to assume prescribed torques (like those in Chiltons or at the UK site) assume one is not using anti-seize on new bolts. Oxygen sensor directions say to use a particular antiseize (included with the sensor in some or all cases). The manuals say then torque to such-and-such.

Sorry Abeness. At this point I can draw only from my own experience: Except for spark plugs, anti-seize early and often, then torque to spec (without adjustment).
 
Nope. http://www.honda.co.uk/owner/AccordManual/400/5-36.pdf page 2, "Apply oil to the bolt threads."

Apologies. Page 6-22 of th'91 Integra manual: Oil on threads, but not bolt face. I had it backwards.

Still, the presence of oil changes the dynamic friction versus dry, otherwise why specify?

Caroline
"20+ years with anti-seize."

The same here.
 
Caroline said:
Sorry Abeness. At this point I can draw only from my own experience: Except for spark plugs, anti-seize early and often, then torque to spec (without adjustment).

Well, I've followed this discussion with interest, and I'm still confused. It makes perfect sense to my mind that lubrication would affect the amount of torque to apply, because it reduces friction, thereby making it easier for the bolt threads to slide on and "pull" the threads of the hole (and therefore strip them with less torque). I don't know why a bolt would be any different than a spark plug: they both have threads, and screw into the engine block--or in this case the tranny housing.

Where is a mechanical engineer when you need one? I would assume, perhaps erroneously, that if Honda specified a drop of oil on the crankshaft pulley bolt but not for other bolts, that the torque specified for other bolts is that prescribed for non-lubed threads. Whether that is teh case or not would be anyone's guess. Perhaps I'll try to contact Honda engineering to inquire.

In the meantime, I suspect I'll do what I usually do in these cases: be careful, and sensitive to the "feel" of the situation. Truth is, I can tighten the sucker to a reasonable degree, then check it after a few days' use and see if it's still tight. If not, I'd tighten it a tad more.
 
Abeness said:
Well, I've followed this discussion with interest, and I'm still confused. It makes perfect sense to my mind that lubrication would affect the amount of torque to apply, because it reduces friction, thereby making it easier for the bolt threads to slide on and "pull" the threads of the hole (and therefore strip them with less torque). I don't know why a bolt would be any different than a spark plug: they both have threads, and screw into the engine block--or in this case the tranny housing.

They're not. The distinction I was attempting to draw is that this problem of overtorquing spark plugs arguably is related to the fact that the spark plug threads are brand new, never been used.

New bolts of any kind will have the same problem, as I'm sure you know, depending on what is specified re torquing it dry or torquing it with some kind of lubricant.
Where is a mechanical engineer when you need one?

Here (to be a total ass), but I flubbed this one. It's not exactly a topic covered in engineering classes at the undergraduate level. A bit specialized and more likely something whose detail (e.g. bolt tension) is more likely to be learned in industry when one is actually required to design something, liaison with the manufacturers, and then test it. In my experience. Or that's my pathetic excuse. :-)

Despite my flubbing it, the basic principle (that Tegger first put forth) should be obvious to most anyone with a bit of hands on experience. A lot of DIYers talk about the basic idea at their web sites, too. I wasn't convinced until I came to the comments from GM in the tech article and then to a site where someone had a lab that could measure bolt tension (not for the DIYer) and actually did some tests on bolts with and without lube.

Then again, just a few weeks ago torque was discussed in an auto class I was taking, and while anti-seize was broken out often in the lab, no one said a word about adjusting the torque to be applied. The instructor was very competent, too. Maybe he was just a bit rushed.
I would assume,
perhaps erroneously, that if Honda specified a drop of oil on the crankshaft pulley bolt but not for other bolts, that the torque specified for other bolts is that prescribed for non-lubed threads. Whether that is teh case or not would be anyone's guess. Perhaps I'll try to contact Honda engineering to inquire.

I recently noticed that Chilton's manuals for many American vehicles like Fords give a range of torque specs. In Honda manuals, a single value is given.

This might be related to our discussion.
In the meantime, I suspect I'll do what I usually do in these cases: be careful, and sensitive to the "feel" of the situation. Truth is, I can tighten the sucker to a reasonable degree, then check it after a few days' use and see if it's still tight. If not, I'd tighten it a tad more.

I suspect dealer and independent shop technicians do the same. Torque wrenches are rarely broken out. Yet cars get repaired, and only once in a while does one here of a bolt not properly tightened.
 
Caroline said:
The distinction I was attempting to draw is that this problem of overtorquing spark plugs arguably is related to the fact that the spark plug threads are brand new, never been used.

And because they have been precoated, acc. to the GM quote, presumably with a lubricant since the quote goes on to refer to the antiseize compound as "added insurance". I don't know that other types of new bolts are precoated. But I really know very little about bolts and threads...
Here (to be a total ass), but I flubbed this one.

Mistakes happen, few admit them. No "total asshood" witnessed here. I should've specified "bolt torque expert". ;-))
to a site where someone had a lab that could measure bolt tension (not for the DIYer) and actually did some tests on bolts with and without lube.

Could you post the link? I'd be interested in seeing it myself.
I suspect dealer and independent shop technicians do the same. Torque wrenches are rarely broken out. Yet cars get repaired, and only once in a while does one here of a bolt not properly tightened.

Yeah. I've tightened lots of bolts in my day, never used a torque wrench, and rarely had a problem. I bought a torque wrench for my Honda work because the aluminum block makes me nervous (had nice solid gas-guzzling steel blocks previously)--I expect the "feel" will have to be relearned for aluminum, so I'll go easy at first.

I also wonder what the "wiggle room" is for the Honda torque specs. As you note, they specify a single value while others specify a range. How close to max supported torque are those specs? Probably only a Honda engineer would know.
 
Abeness said:
Could you post the link? I'd be interested in seeing it myself.

http://home.att.net/~benmlee/threads/threads.htm

I'm not a fan of reports on personal web sites, but this guy's direct, hands-on experience (with spacecraft fastener testing) applied to this little study impressed me.
Yeah. I've tightened lots of bolts in my day, never used a torque wrench, and rarely had a problem. I bought a torque wrench for my Honda work because the aluminum block makes me nervous (had nice solid gas-guzzling steel blocks previously)--I expect the "feel" will have to be relearned for aluminum, so I'll go easy at first.

The valve cover was a big impetus for me to buy a torque wrench.

Otherwise, like you, until recently most of my car work has been without a torque wrench. Work in industry was a mixed bag. Nuclear: Shucks yes.
Non-nuclear: Time is money.
I also wonder what the "wiggle room" is for the Honda torque specs. As you note, they specify a single value while others specify a range. How close to max supported torque are those specs? Probably only a Honda engineer would know.

Have you noticed the front section of many Chilton manuals talks about torques and gives a table of recommended torque ranges for different sized bolts as a guideline? Which can be found on the Internet at various sites, too. E.g. at Autozone for 1984-1995 Civics under "Tools and Equipment":
Bolts marked 6T
6mm bolt/nut: 5-7 ft. lbs.
8mm bolt/nut: 12-17 ft. lbs.
10mm bolt/nut: 23-34 ft. lbs.
12mm bolt/nut: 41-59 ft. lbs.
14mm bolt/nut: 56-76 ft. lbs.

Like you said, the stuff of bolt specialists.

Also, I for one try not to assume too much when I apply bolt specs. After all, rarely am I working with brand new bolts. What the rust, general deformation of threads, etc. do to bolt tension for a given torque over time involves I think consideration of

1. Using antiseize on older bolts that display minor galling.
2. Replacing really old bolts (having worn threads)
3. Torquing to lower end of spec, or possibly reduce the torque spec "some" amount, when using anti-seize on newer bolts.
4. God knows what temperature changes do to the whole calculation. (Well, we have some idea: Bolts stretch as they're heated and so tend to loosen.)
 
Caroline said:
Otherwise, like you, until recently most of my car work has been without a torque wrench. Work in industry was a mixed bag. Nuclear: Shucks yes.

I wonder why...
Have you noticed the front section of many Chilton manuals talks about torques and gives a table of recommended torque ranges for different sized bolts as a guideline?

I've never paid much attention to bolt torques, for reasons described previously, so no. I went right to the Helm manual for my Honda, skipped Chilton's/Haynes entirely after some reports of errors, and I wanted the full monty.
Also, I for one try not to assume too much when I apply bolt specs.

A wise practice. Thanks for the link.
 
"Caroline" sprach im

I suspect dealer and independent shop technicians do the same. Torque wrenches are rarely broken out. Yet cars get repaired, and only once in a while does one here of a bolt not properly tightened.

That's because they tighten until it "feels right". It's learned by experience.

I do the same with anything I can't get a torque wrench on or if I don't know what the torque should be.
 
TeGGer® said:
That's because they tighten until it "feels right". It's learned by experience.

I believe this "experience" of which you speak has no relation to actually testing the feel of, say, 26 ft-lbs. of torque. Instead, it's "Feels tight. Must be right." I have a vague recollection of a study that showed what numerical torque people hoped to achieve and what they actually achieved were widely different.

One data point: The many anecdotes about lug nuts not torqued to spec, but to what the operator felt was right, and the warped rotor etc. outcomes of this.

Sorry, but I had a chance to watch a gaggle of shadetree mechanics (self-decribed "experts") over the course of several weeks not long ago, and watching them wrap their ego around their wrong-headedness was fascinating.

(For the record, I don't find a shadetree mechanic approach here at the group, for the most part. And yup, I still find the typical, say five years of experience, shadetree mechanic smarter than an MD. Which is a comment on doctors... ;-) )
I do the same with anything I can't get a torque wrench

Yup. And I don't lose sleep over it when I do. But this is after years of experience.

OTOH, who here with 20 years experience with tightening bolts has never stripped one or sheared off a head? Or had one come loose?
on or if I don't
know what the torque should be.

These days when this happens I use the various tables available for automotive fasteners.
 
Abeness said:
I've never paid much attention to bolt torques, for reasons described previously, so no. I went right to the Helm manual for my Honda, skipped Chilton's/Haynes entirely after some reports of errors, and I wanted the full monty.

A wise practice. Thanks for the link.

Likewise, re the link from Bolt Science (in the other thread you started).
Nice site.

I couldn't resist seeing if there was commentary on how to use the torque ranges in the Ford Chilton manuals. I checked and couldn't find anything. But for the record, some examples of ranges from the Chilton manual for Ford Full Size Vans, 1989-1996:

Wheel lug nuts on 1996 E-250: 126-170 ft-lbs
Shock absorber top mount nut: 25-35 ft-lbs.
Brake caliper mounting bolts: 22-26 ft-lbs.
Exhaust manifold bolts: 18-24 ft-lbs.
Stabilizer bar lock nut: 40-60 ft-lbs.
Oil pan bolts: 9-12 ft lbs.

So for this sample, the specified torque varies from 18% to 50% higher than the lowest value of toque specified.

Many Chilton manuals also have the following commentary (very much in the same vein as some of the material at the boltscience.com site):

[Paraphrasing] When tightening a bolt, torque ends up being "distributed" over three regions:
50% -- overcomes friction between the bolt head and the base surface 40% -- overcomes thread friction 10% -- develops a useful clamp load (which is where bolt tension and the whole purpose of a bolt come in)

These %s reinforce Tegger's original point: Change the friction between threads (or head and base) a little, and it will re-distribute a given applied torque such that bolt tension rises (for better or worse, as the application indicates).

What to shoot for? To me, the point is that achieving the correct holding power (a.k.a. clamping force) is a fairly inexact science (which of course is true of most engineering, depending on how one defines "exact"). One just can't consistently estimate with much "accuracy" the frictional resisting force for a given bolt that's been used many times. It's going to change over time, too, probably. But this should make no one uncomfortable. Factors of safety make the world go round. Start at the lower end of the torque range. If the bolt comes loose sooner than expected, increase the torque.

Also, one's torque wrench may, after years of use, be off by as much as say, 20%. A big deal? I'd say only with respect to undertorquing.

After all this, I suppose I'd regret my torque wrench purchases of the last year except that they do ensure uniformity on, for example, lug nut bolts and valve covers. That's half the battle in ensuring a secure wheel, valve cover, etc.
 
Caroline said:
OTOH, who here with 20 years experience with tightening bolts has never stripped one or sheared off a head? Or had one come loose?

stripped? yes. big steel bolt, aluminum part :)

sheared? yes. not uncommon when *removing* siezed fasteners. cant recall shearing one off while tightening.

loose? only when using worn fasteners, and no loctite, on a buzzy 80cc scooter engine. i eventually got it right, but the vibration caused parts of the exhaust to crack, so i learned arc welding as well.

it was either $120 for a new exhaust, or $150 for a small arc welder. i spent the extra bucks and learned a new skill :)
 

Latest threads

Back
Top